Categories

Alarmist Predictions

More fun with unintended consequences

In yesterday’s post I wrote, it’s a cosmic rule that hippie action is always met by the equal and opposte force of unintended consequences.

The karmic Universe of unintended consequences also has a cosmic cluebat for the EPA and the Clean Air Act.

It turns out that cleaner air makes global warming worse:

An Irish scientist at NUI Galway originally initiated the research into how air pollution has a hidden beneficial side. It shows the haze that forms due to pollution, the tiny particles discharged by motor transport, and smoke from burning help to reflect back some of the solar radiation that is warming our climate. If we manage to clean up the pollution we may also ramp up warming, said Prof Colin O’Dowd, professor of physics at Galway and also director of the Centre for Climate and Air Pollution Studies at the Ryan Institute.

Cleaner air causes global warming. Add it to The List. Wait, what?

pesky universe

The EPA’s efforts to save us from global warming caused by coal plants, medium sized sedans and anything that makes modern life tolerably cozy, have instead doomed us to a future of slightly milder weather. Oh the ironing:

The results are shocking given their calculations on this masking, published yesterday in Atmospheric Physics and Chemistry. Cleaner air could increase average global temperatures by 1 degree globally and by between 2-4 degrees over Europe.

The good news is the claim is made by a climate scientist, so the math is likely to be off by a factor of funding, or something.

[ad#insert-large]

9 comments to More fun with unintended consequences

  • Greg

    ‘The good news is the claim is made by a climate scientist, so the math is likely to be off by a factor of funding, or something.”

    Heh. Perfect. :)

  • tadchem

    So everything causes global warming, including the prevention of global warming?
    I am reminded of a study that was run back in the 70′s - a computer model.
    No matter which of several parameters was tweaked, *any* variation from the initial conditions caused the forecasts to ‘blow up.’
    Because the investigators were not naive enough to assume that their initial guess arrived at optimum values for the parameters, it could only be inferred that something else was going on.
    When the investigators kept the initial parameters the same, but reduced the time increment step size, the forecasts *still* blew up.
    The culprit turned out to be accumulated round-off error.
    Because digital computers *must* round off numbers at some point, and the common algorithm in use in all computers at the time rounded up a few percent more frequently than they rounded down (i.e. when the digit to be rounded was a 5, they always rounded up, instead of only half the time), that few percent excess of rounding-up was causing noticeable accumulated upward error after millions of calculations.
    By the time they had puzzled this out, however, the spurious results had already gone to press…

  • It takes hundreds of years for the atmosphere to dispose of excess CO2

    The atmosphere doesn’t dispose of anything. & based on the past few millions of years, there’s no such thing as “excess CO2″.

  • Graham

    “burn less coal to reduce anthropogenic global warming. It reduces carbon pollution and other pollution.”

    “carbon pollution” is soot, Steve L. If you mean carbon dioxide, that is not pollution.

    By “other pollution” presumably you mean particulate matter (smog, including soot). Have you read this post? Reducing that pollution doesn’t reduce temperature, it increases it. So again my question: How much of the increase in global temperature in industrial times is attributable to clearing the skies of smog? After all, it’s been established by empirical evidence that the plant food, CO2, is not responsible.

    http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/politics/an-inconvenient-fallacy-20110626-1glmu.html

  • Steve L

    This isn’t new. You can read it all over the place in even the most conventional climate change websites. Here’s an example from Realclimate in 2005
    http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2005/01/global-dimming/
    When you hear someone say, “More than 100% of the warming is caused by anthropogenic greenhouse gases,” you should know they are referring to the cooling effect of aerosols. Without those aerosols the world would probably be warmer now.
    When you hear about geoengineering and the idea of spreading sulfates in the stratosphere, that’s basically the same phenomenon. But by putting aerosols into the stratosphere (like volcanic eruptions with big effects on global temperature Mt Pinatubo and El Chichon), the effect is longer lasting than emissions from the simple burning of coal at ground level. Thus a better cooling bang per pollution buck, though still with problems.

    I don’t think there’s anything controversial in wanting to burn less coal to reduce anthropogenic global warming. It reduces carbon pollution and other pollution. There’s no “gotcha” here.

  • Graham

    Expanding Grumpy Old Man’s experience, to what extent does the reduction in smog globally explain the warming now attributed by alarmists to CO2?

  • Grumpy Old Man (UK)

    One of my earliest memories is the smogs of 1950′s London. I’m sure that Los Angeles inhabitants will agree with me when I say that a rise in temperature is a price worth paying for breathable air.

  • Jay Alt

    That is hardly a surprise. Since the late 1970s and 80s, scientists worked to quantify the effects of two processes - the build up of CO2 and the simultaneous cooling of aerosols. Both come from the same sources - auto & power plant air pollution. The former was found to be the stronger effect and longer lasting. It takes hundreds of years for the atmosphere to dispose of excess CO2 versus weeks or months for small particles to be washed out about by rain.